Mr. Biden assigned Jake Sullivan, his countrywide protection adviser, to run an interagency assessment of Afghanistan plan that resulted in 10 conferences of division deputies, three cabinet-degree conferences and 4 meetings in the Predicament Place that involved the president.
The Biden team regarded other selections, together with maintaining a modest existence of troops for counterterrorism functions or to assistance Afghan safety forces, but reasoned that was just “magical thinking” and would acquire more troops than was sustainable. They reviewed whether or not to renegotiate the Trump arrangement to extract far more concessions but the Taliban created distinct it would not return to the bargaining desk and regarded as the Trump offer binding.
Mr. Biden’s advisers also regarded extending the withdrawal deadline right up until the winter, just after the traditional combating year was over, to make the transition a lot less harmful for the Afghan federal government. The Afghanistan Study Group, a bipartisan congressionally chartered panel that was led by Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., a retired Joint Chiefs chairman and that incorporated Ms. O’Sullivan, in February recommended extending the May perhaps 1 deadline and seeking improved problems before pulling out.
But Mr. Biden was warned by security experts that the for a longer time it took to withdraw immediately after a decision was introduced, the much more perilous it would grow to be, aides mentioned, so he extended it only until Aug. 31.
Significantly influential on Mr. Biden, aides reported, were a series of intelligence assessments he asked for about Afghanistan’s neighbors and in the vicinity of neighbors, which observed that Russia and China wanted the United States to stay bogged down in Afghanistan.
At the stop of the working day, then, the officers explained each individual selection eventually led to a single of the two final solutions — get out entirely, as Mr. Trump experienced agreed to do, or put together for a prolonged and a lot more dangerous taking pictures war with several a lot more troops. Although not every person in the home desired Mr. Biden’s route, officers maintained that every person was listened to.
“Biden basically confronted the same situation that Trump confronted,” said Vali Nasr, who was a senior adviser to Richard C. Holbrooke, Mr. Obama’s special consultant on Afghanistan and Pakistan, “and his answer was the exact same — we’re not heading to go back again in, we have to get out.”